Middle schoolers are wonderful company, though it doesn’t always feel that way at 8:00 in the morning. One day they’ll give you a one-word answer and a shrug. The next, they’ll argue for fifteen minutes about whether Robin Hood was a hero or a thief.
That love of a good argument is a gift, and a question of the day is a simple way to put it to work. Our free Question of the Day for Middle School offers more than 200 discussion prompts written for students in grades six through eight. Some are light and fun. Many ask students to take a side and give a reason. All of them are designed to get this age talking, and thinking.
Today’s question Wednesday, November 18
What do you think would happen if bees disappeared?
Choose your questions
Pick the kinds of questions you’d like. Today’s question and your plan follow your choices.
Plan your school days
Weekends are skipped. Lock the questions you love, swap the rest, write your own, and remove any days off. Your plan is saved in this browser.
Share or print
Show your plan on screen one day at a time, copy it, or print it.
How to Use the Question of the Day in Middle School
The tool above opens with today’s question. Filter by the kinds of questions you want, choose quick or discussion-length prompts, and shuffle whenever you like. Teachers can put the question on screen in large type, and the planner fills a whole stretch of school days so you can lock favorites, write your own, and print the schedule.
Here are a few ways teachers and homeschool parents use it:
- As a bell ringer. Put the question up as students arrive and give them two minutes to write an answer before class begins.
- As a journal prompt. A discussion question makes a natural paragraph assignment: answer, then give one reason.
- As a quick debate. Ask students to stand on one side of the room or the other, then let each side make its case.
- In small groups. Groups of three or four give every student a chance to speak, especially the quieter ones.
- At home. Bring the day’s question to dinner. Middle schoolers often enjoy a conversation more when they get to hear their parents’ answers too.
Why Middle School Is the Perfect Age for a Daily Question
Somewhere around sixth grade, many children discover the word “why” all over again, and this time they mean it as a challenge. They notice when an argument doesn’t hold together. They want to know the reasons behind the rules.
Dorothy Sayers, in her 1947 essay “The Lost Tools of Learning,” gave this stage a playful name: the “Pert” age, when children love to contradict and catch others out. Rather than seeing this as a problem, she argued it was the right moment to teach formal logic and the art of argument. Classical educators still call these years the logic or dialectic stage (The Trivium Explained).
A middle schooler’s love of argument is a gift waiting to be trained.
That’s why so many of these questions invite students to weigh two sides: Is it fair to treat everyone exactly the same? Is it ever okay to break a promise? What is the difference between confidence and pride? Each one gives students practice in the skill they’re most eager to use, which is building an argument and defending it.
The Kinds of Questions You’ll Find
- Casual: “If you could ask your future self one question, what would it be?”
- Great Ideas: “What is the difference between being alone and being lonely?”
- History: “Why do you think the Black Death changed Europe so much?”
- Literature: “Why do you think Edmund betrayed his brother and sisters?”
- Science: “Should people try to live on Mars someday?”
- Math and Logic: “Why do you think Roman numerals have no symbol for zero?”
- Theology: “Why do you think God spoke to Elijah in a quiet whisper?”
- Art and Music: “What is the difference between music you dance to and music you think to?”
Many questions come with a short note “for the conversation,” such as a date, a Scripture reference, or the book a question comes from, so you can lead the discussion with confidence.
Getting Past the Shrug
If your students sometimes meet a great question with silence or an eye roll, you’re not alone. Middle schoolers can be very aware of how they look in front of their peers, and saying something sincere can feel risky. That hesitation makes a lot of sense, and it usually softens once students see that their ideas are welcome.
- Ask them to choose a side. “Agree or disagree?” is easier to answer than an open question, and the reasons come naturally after.
- Let them write first. Thirty seconds with a pencil gives every student something to say before anyone speaks.
- Take their answers seriously. Respond to the reasoning, and ask “What would someone on the other side say?”
- Let them question you. Middle schoolers love the chance to challenge the adult’s answer, and it models good-natured disagreement.
You’ll find more practical ideas in Three Simple Fixes for Fizzling Discussions and 3 Ways to Draw Quiet Children into Discussion.
From Good Questions to Good Arguments
At Veritas Press, we love teaching this age. Middle school is when we introduce formal logic, giving students the tools to tell a sound argument from a clever-sounding one (Why Studying Logic Is So Important). It’s also when many students begin Omnibus, our Great Books course, where every reading comes with a “Question to Consider” that frames the discussion (Leading Omnibus Discussions). A daily question builds the same habits in small, everyday doses.
Ready for deeper conversations?
See how middle school at Veritas Scholars Academy turns a love of argument into clear thinking.
Frequently Asked Questions
What grades are these questions for?
They’re written for sixth through eighth grade. Advanced fifth graders and some ninth graders will enjoy them too. You can also browse questions for kids and high school students.
What makes a good question of the day for middle school?
Questions that invite students to take a position and explain it work especially well at this age. Middle schoolers enjoy weighing two sides, so questions like “Is Robin Hood a hero or a thief?” tend to spark more conversation than questions with a single right answer.
How long should a question of the day take?
It depends on your goal. Quick questions take about a minute and work well as a warm-up. Discussion questions can fill ten minutes or more. Use the Length filter to choose.
Can I plan questions for the whole semester?
Yes. Choose a start date and up to 180 school days in the planner. Weekends are skipped automatically, and you can remove holidays, swap questions, or write your own before printing.
